From mboxrd@z Thu Jan 1 00:00:00 1970 Return-Path: X-Spam-Checker-Version: SpamAssassin 3.4.1 (2015-04-28) on sa.local.altlinux.org X-Spam-Level: X-Spam-Status: No, score=-4.3 required=5.0 tests=ALL_TRUSTED,BAYES_00, RP_MATCHES_RCVD autolearn=unavailable autolearn_force=no version=3.4.1 From: =?koi8-r?B?5M3J1NLJyiDkxdLWwdfJzg==?= To: Open-source aspects of GOST Cryptography References: <20181204065445.gcaguhhvh7z6gajf@sole.flsd.net> Date: Wed, 05 Dec 2018 10:35:05 +0300 In-Reply-To: <20181204065445.gcaguhhvh7z6gajf@sole.flsd.net> (Vitaly Chikunov's message of "Tue, 4 Dec 2018 09:54:45 +0300") Message-ID: <87bm60qvdi.fsf@asia.home.dd> User-Agent: Gnus/5.13 (Gnus v5.13) Emacs/25.3 (gnu/linux) MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=utf-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64 Subject: Re: [oss-gost-crypto] EC-RDSA and a key substitution attack X-BeenThere: oss-gost-crypto@lists.altlinux.org X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.12 Precedence: list Reply-To: Open-source aspects of GOST Cryptography List-Id: Open-source aspects of GOST Cryptography List-Unsubscribe: , List-Archive: List-Post: List-Help: List-Subscribe: , X-List-Received-Date: Wed, 05 Dec 2018 07:35:09 -0000 Archived-At: List-Archive: 0JLRgiwgMDQg0LTQtdC6IDIwMTgsIDA5OjU0LCBWaXRhbHkgQ2hpa3Vub3Y6DQoNCj4gICBOT1RF IDUgVGhlIG1lY2hhbmlzbXMgb2YgRUMtRFNBLCBFQy1HRFNBLiBFQy1SRFNBIGFuZCBFQy1GU0RT QSBtYXkgYmUNCj4gICB2dWxuZXJhYmxlIHRvIGEga2V5IHN1YnN0aXR1dGlvbiBhdHRhY2tbMTBd LiBb4oCmXQ0KPg0KPiDQk9C00LUgRUMtUkRTQSDRjdGC0L4g0JPQntCh0KIg0KAgMzQuMTAtMjAw MSAo0LAg0LfQvdCw0YfQuNGCINC4IDM0LjEwLTIwMTIpLg0KPg0KPiDQndCwINGB0LrQvtC70YzQ utC+INGN0YLQsCDQsNGC0LDQutCwINCw0LrRgtGD0LDQu9GM0L3QsCDQtNC70Y8g0JPQntCh0KLQ sCDQuNC70Lgg0Y3RgtC+INC+0YfQtdGA0LXQtNC90L7QuSDQvdCw0LPQvtCy0L7RgCDQvdCwDQo+ INGA0L7RgdGB0LjQudGB0LrRg9GOINC60YDQuNC/0YLQvtCz0YDQsNGE0LjRjiDQsiDRgdGC0LjQ u9C1INCdLiDQmtGD0YDRgtGD0LA/DQoNCtCS0L7Qv9GA0L7RgSDQvdC10L7QtNC90L7QutGA0LDR gtC90L4g0L7QsdGB0YPQttC00LDQu9GB0Y8uINCd0LDQv9GA0LjQvNC10YAsINC/0L4t0LzQvtC1 0LzRgywg0YLRg9GCOg0KaHR0cHM6Ly9ldmVudHMueWFuZGV4LnJ1L2xpYi90YWxrcy8yOTcwLw0K DQo+INCU0L7QsdCw0LLQuNGC0Ywgc2lnbmluZyBrZXkg0LogbWVzc2FnZSDQvdC1INGB0LvQvtC2 0L3Qviwg0L3QviDRjyDQuNGB0YXQvtC20YMg0LjQtyDRgtC+0LPQviwg0YfRgtC+DQo+INGN0YLQ vtCz0L4g0LTQtdC70LDRgtGMINC90LUg0L3QsNC00L4sINGC0LDQuiDQutCw0Log0LIg0JPQntCh 0KLQtSDRgtCw0LrQvtCz0L4g0L3QtdGCLiDQndC+INC10YHQu9C4INCx0Ysg0LHRi9C7DQo+INGA 0LXQutC+0LzQtdC90LTQvtCy0LDQvdC90YvQuSDQvNC10YLQvtC0INGE0L7RgNC80LjRgNC+0LLQ sNC90LjRjyDQv9C+0LTQv9C40YHQuCDRgSDRg9GH0LXRgtC+0Lwg0Y3RgtC+0Lkg0LDRgtCw0LrQ uCwg0YLQvg0KPiDQtNGA0YPQs9C+0LUg0LTQtdC70L4uDQoNCtCSINC+0LHRidC10LwsINGN0YLQ viwg0LLQuNC00LjQvNC+LCDQuCDQtdGB0YLRjCDRgNC10LrQvtC80LXQvdC00L7QstCw0L3QvdGL 0Lkg0LzQtdGC0L7QtC4g0KHQv9GA0L7RgdC40Lsg0YMg0KHQvNGL0YjQu9GP0LXQstCwLA0K0LLQ vtGCINGH0YLQviDQvtC9INC+0YLQstC10YLQuNC7Og0KDQrCq9CU0LAsINGN0YLQviDQuNC30LLQ tdGB0YLQvdC+0LUg0YHQstC+0LnRgdGC0LLQviDRgdGF0LXQvCDQvdCwINC+0YHQvdC+0LLQtSDQ utC+0L3RgdGC0YDRg9C60YbQuNC4INCt0LvRjC3Qk9Cw0LzQsNC70Y8sINCyDQrRgi7Rhy4g0L3Q sNGI0LXQs9C+INCT0J7QodCiINCgIDM0LjEwLg0KDQrQkiDRgNC+0YHRgdC40LnRgdC60L7QuSDQ u9C40YLQtdGA0LDRgtGD0YDQtSDQuNC90L7Qs9C00LAg0LLRgdGC0YDQtdGH0LDQtdGC0YHRjyDQ utCw0LogItCw0YLQsNC60LAg0JPRgNGD0L3RgtC+0LLQuNGH0LAiLg0KaHR0cDovL2l0c2VjLnJ1 L2FydGljbGVzMi9jcnlwdG8vc2VydGlmaXRzaXJvdmFubnllLXNremktY2h0by1udXpobm8tem5h dC0tY2h0b2J5LXByYXZpbG5vLWloLXZ5YnJhdA0KDQrQpNCw0LrRgtC40YfQtdGB0LrQuCDQv9GA 0Lgg0LjRgdC/0L7Qu9GM0LfQvtCy0LDQvdC40Lgg0L3QsCDQv9GA0LDQutGC0LjQutC1INC70LDQ vdC00YjQsNGE0YIg0LTQu9GPINC/0YDQvtCy0LXQtNC10L3QuNGPINCw0YLQsNC60LgNCtGB0L7Q t9C00LDRgtGMINC90LUg0YPQtNCw0YHRgtGB0Y8g0L/QviDRgdC70LXQtNGD0Y7RidC40Lwg0L/R gNC40YfQuNC90LDQvDoNCg0KMSkg0KHQtdGA0YLQuNGE0LjRhtC40YDQvtCy0LDQvdC90YvQtSDQ odCa0JfQmCDQvdC1INC00LDRjtGCINCy0L7Qt9C80L7QttC90L7RgdGC0Lgg0YfQtdGA0LXQtyBB UEkg0YTQuNC60YHQuNGA0L7QstCw0YLRjA0K0LfQvdCw0YfQtdC90LjQtSDQt9Cw0LrRgNGL0YLQ vtCz0L4g0LrQu9GO0YfQsCwg0L7QvSDRgdC+0LfQtNCw0LXRgtGB0Y8g0YLQvtC70YzQutC+INGB INC/0L7QvNC+0YnRjNGOINCy0YHRgtGA0L7QtdC90L3Ri9GFDQrQlNCh0KcuINCl0L7RgtGPLCDQ utC+0L3QtdGH0L3Qviwg0L/QvtC0INC+0YLQu9Cw0LTRh9C40LrQvtC8INC90LDRgNGD0YjQuNGC 0LXQu9GMINCy0L/QvtC70L3QtSDQvNC+0LbQtdGCINGN0YLQviDQvtCx0L7QudGC0LguDQoNCjIp INCt0LvQtdC60YLRgNC+0L3QvdCw0Y8g0L/QvtC00L/QuNGB0Ywg0LjQvNC10LXRgiDRgdC80YvR gdC7INCyINC00L7QutGD0LzQtdC90YLQvtC+0LHQvtGA0L7RgtC1INGC0L7Qu9GM0LrQviDQutCw 0Log0K3QnywNCtGE0L7RgNC80LjRgNGD0LXQvNCw0Y8g0L3QsCDQutC70Y7Rh9Cw0YUsINC90LAg 0L7RgtC60YDRi9GC0YvQtSDQutC+0LzQv9C+0L3QtdC90YLRiyDQutC+0YLQvtGA0YvRhSDQstGL 0LTQsNC90YsNCtGB0LXRgNGC0LjRhNC40LrQsNGC0Ysg0LIg0KPQpiAo0LDQutC60YDQtdC00LjR gtC+0LLQsNC90L3QvtC8INCyINGB0LvRg9GH0LDQtSDQutCy0LDQu9C40YTQuNGG0LjRgNC+0LLQ sNC90L3QvtC5INCt0J8g0LjQu9C4INCj0KYNCtGBINCy0L3Rg9GC0YDQtdC90L3QuNC8INGA0LXQ s9C70LDQvNC10L3RgtC+0Lwg0LIg0YHQu9GD0YfQsNC1LCDQvdCw0L/RgNC40LzQtdGALCDQstC9 0YPRgtGA0LXQvdC90LXQuSDQv9C+0LTQv9C40YHQuCDQsg0K0LHQsNC90LrQtSkuINCQINCj0KYg 0LrQsNC6INC/0YDQsNCy0LjQu9C+INGA0LDQsdC+0YLQsNGO0YIg0L/QviDRgdGF0LXQvNC1LCDQ v9GA0LXQtNC/0L7Qu9Cw0LPQsNGO0YnQtdC5INCz0LXQvdC10YDQsNGG0LjRjg0K0LrQu9GO0YfQ sCDQvdCwINCQ0KDQnNC1INC90LAg0YLQtdGA0YDQuNGC0L7RgNC40Lgg0YHQsNC80L7Qs9C+INCj 0KYuDQoNCjMpINCd0LAg0L/RgNCw0LrRgtC40LrQtSDQsiDQtNC+0LrRg9C80LXQvdGC0L7QvtCx 0L7RgNC+0YLQtSDQrdCfINC/0YDQuNC80LXQvdGP0LXRgtGB0Y8g0L3QtSDQsNCx0Ysg0LrQsNC6 LCDQsCDQsg0K0YTQvtGA0LzQsNGC0LDRhSBDQWRFUywgUEFkRVMg0Lgg0L/RgC4gLSDRgNCw0YHR iNC40YDQtdC90L3Ri9GFINGE0L7RgNC80LDRgtCw0YUsINC/0YDQtdC00L7RgdGC0LDQstC70Y/R jtGJ0LjRhQ0K0LjQvdGE0L7RgNC80LDRhtC40Y4g0L4g0YHQtdGA0YLQuNGE0LjQutCw0YLQsNGF Lg0KDQo0KSDQnNCw0YHRgdC+0LLQviDRgNCw0YHQv9GA0L7RgdGC0YDQsNC90Y/QtdC80LDRjyDR gdC10LnRh9Cw0YEg0L7QsdC70LDRh9C90LDRjyDQv9C+0LTQv9C40YHRjCAo0YHQvC4g0JrRgNC4 0L/RgtC+0J/RgNC+IERTUw0K0LjQu9C4IFNhZmVUZWNoIG15RFNTKSAtINGB0YDQtdC00YHRgtCy 0L4sINC60L7RgtC+0YDQvtC1INCz0LDRgNCw0L3RgtC40YDQvtCy0LDQvdC+INGD0YHRgtGA0LDQ vdGP0LXRgiDRjdGC0YMNCtC/0YDQvtCx0LvQtdC80YMsINGC0LDQuiDQutCw0Log0LrQu9GO0YfQ uCDQs9C10L3QtdGA0Y/RgtGB0Y8g0LIgSFNNINC4INC90LUg0LjQt9Cy0LvQtdC60LDRjtGC0YHR jyDQuNC3INC90LXQs9C+Lg0KDQrQmtC+0L3QtdGH0L3Qviwg0L/RgNC4INCy0YHQtdC8INC/0YDQ uCDRjdGC0L7QvCDRgdCw0LzQsCDRgNC10LDQu9C40LfQsNGG0LjRjyDQv9GA0LjQvNC40YLQuNCy 0LAg0L7RgdGC0LDQtdGC0YHRjyDQutCw0Log0LHRiw0K0LHQtdC3INC80LXRgCDQt9Cw0YnQuNGC 0Ysg0L/RgNC+0YLQuNCyINGC0LDQutC+0LPQviDRgNC+0LTQsCDQsNGC0LDQui4g0J3QviDQuCDQ v9GA0LjQvNC10L3Rj9GO0YIg0LXQtSDQvdC1INCyINGH0LjRgdGC0L7QvA0K0LLQuNC00LUsINCw INCyINGB0LjRgdGC0LXQvNCw0YUuINCh0L7QsdGB0YLQstC10L3QvdC+LCDQt9Cw0YnQuNGC0LAg 0L/RgNC+0YLQuNCyINC/0L7QtNC+0LHQvdGL0YUg0LDRgtCw0Log0L3QsCDRgdC40YHRgtC10LzR gw0K0Lgg0Y/QstC70Y/QtdGC0YHRjyDQvtC00L3QuNC8INC40Lcg0LLQvtC/0YDQvtGB0L7Qsiwg 0YDQsNGB0YHQvNCw0YLRgNC40LLQsNC10LzRi9GFINCyINC/0YDQvtGG0LXRgdGB0LUg0YHQtdGA 0YLQuNGE0LjQutCw0YbQuNC4DQrQodCa0JfQmCAo0YEg0L/RgNC40LrQu9Cw0LTQvdGL0LzQuCDQ utC+0LzQv9C+0L3QtdC90YLQsNC80LgpINC4INC60L7QvdGC0YDQvtC70Y8g0LLRgdGC0YDQsNC4 0LLQsNC90LjRjyDQsiDQpNCh0JEg0KDQvtGB0YHQuNC4Lg0KDQrQl9Cw0YnQuNGJ0LDRgtGM0YHR jyDQvtGCINGN0YLQvtCz0L4g0L3QsCDQvdC40LbQvdC10Lwg0YPRgNC+0LLQvdC1LCDQstCy0L7Q tNGPINC90LXQutC40Lkg0YHQsNC80L7Qv9C40YHQvdGL0Lkg0YTQvtGA0LzQsNGCDQoo0L/RgNC4 INGC0L7QvCwg0YfRgtC+INC4INGC0LDQuiDQtdGB0YLRjCDRg9C/0L7QvNGP0L3Rg9GC0YvQtSDQ stGL0YjQtSBDQWRFUyDQuCDQv9GA0L7Rh9C40LUsINC30LDRidC40YnQsNGO0YnQuNC1INC+0YIN CtGC0LDQutC+0Lkg0LDRgtCw0LrQuCDQuCDQv9C+0LTQvtCx0L3Ri9GFINC10LkpINC/0L7Qu9Cw 0LPQsNGOINC80LDQu9C+0L7RgdC80YvRgdC70LXQvdC90YvQvC7Cuw0KDQrQntGCINGB0LXQsdGP INC00L7QsdCw0LLQu9GOLCDRh9GC0L4g0LLQsNGA0LjQsNC90YIgwqsywrsg0YEg0LPQtdC90LXR gNCw0YbQuNC10Lkg0LrQu9GO0YfQsCDQsiDQo9CmINCy0YvQs9C70Y/QtNC40YIsDQrQv9C+LdC8 0L7QtdC80YMsINC/0YDQvtGB0YLQviDRg9C20LDRgdC90L4uINCSINC+0YLQu9C40YfQuNC1INC+ 0YIgwqszwrsuINCa0YHRgtCw0YLQuCwgQ0FERVMg0LzRiyDRg9C80LXQtdC8DQrQs9C10L3QtdGA 0LjRgNC+0LLQsNGC0YwuINCd0YMg0L/QvtGH0YLQuCDRg9C80LXQtdC8LiA7KQ0KDQotLSANCtCU 0LzQuNGC0YDQuNC5INCU0LXRgNC20LDQstC40L0sDQpCYXNlQUxUL9CR0LDQt9Cw0LvRjNGCINCh 0J/Qng0K