Re: [devel] Излишнее увлечение макросом %name в спеке

["Dmitry V. Levin" <ldv@altlinux.org>]

On Fri, Mar 22, 2024 at 09:10:19AM +0300, Anton Farygin wrote:
> On 22.03.2024 06:11, Ilya Kurdyukov wrote:
> > Нашел сейчас в atop:
> >
> > URL: http://www.%{name}tool.nl
> >
> > Если мне захочется зайти на сайт, то я должен сначала вставить имя 
> > пакета в URL? 
> 
> Да конечно это ошибка, надо написать где-то на www.altlinux.org в 
> правилах что так делать нельзя.
> 
> URL должен быть кликабельным из specfile из редактора, это удобно и полезно.

Я бы не утверждал так уж категорично.  У нас в Сизифе, например, много
таких вполне валидных конструкций, как %CPAN, например:

$ git --git-dir=/people/specbot/public/specs.git grep -i -h '^URL: %CPAN' @ |sort |uniq -c |sort -nr
    581 URL: %CPAN %dist
    278 Url: %CPAN %module_name
     70 Url: %CPAN %module
     43 Url: %CPAN %dist
     41 Url: %CPAN %m_distro
     35 URL: %CPAN %module
      3 URL: %CPAN %module_name
      2 Url: %CPAN %oname
      1 Url: %CPAN X11-Xlib
      1 Url: %CPAN URI-Find
      1 Url: %CPAN Twiggy
      1 Url: %CPAN TOML
      1 Url: %CPAN Text-Xslate-Bridge-TT2Like
      1 Url: %CPAN Text-Xslate
      1 Url: %CPAN Text-TestBase
      1 Url: %CPAN Text-Markdown-Hoedown
      1 Url: %CPAN Test-Trap
      1 Url: %CPAN Test-TinyMocker
      1 Url: %CPAN Test-TCP
      1 Url: %CPAN Test-Spec
      1 Url: %CPAN Test-SharedFork
      1 Url: %CPAN Test-Requires
      1 Url: %CPAN Test-Most
      1 Url: %CPAN System-Command
      1 Url: %CPAN Sub-Exporter-Progressive
      1 Url: %CPAN strictures
      1 Url: %CPAN Stream-Buffered
      1 Url: %CPAN Starman
      1 Url: %CPAN Specio
      1 Url: %CPAN Socket-Netlink
      1 Url: %CPAN Server-Starter
      1 Url: %CPAN RRDTool-OO
      1 Url: %CPAN Router-Simple-Sinatraish
      1 Url: %CPAN Router-Simple
      1 Url: %CPAN Router-Boom
      1 Url: %CPAN Role-Tiny
      1 URL: %CPAN %real_name
      1 Url: %CPAN Protocol-WebSocket
      1 Url: %CPAN Proc-FastSpawn
      1 Url: %CPAN Plack-Middleware-Session
      1 Url: %CPAN Plack-Middleware-ReverseProxy
      1 Url: %CPAN Plack-Middleware-ETag
      1 Url: %CPAN Plack
      1 Url: %CPAN Parse-Functions
      1 Url: %CPAN OpenGL
      1 Url: %CPAN Object-Event
      1 Url: %CPAN Object-Container
      1 Url: %CPAN Net-Twitter
      1 Url: %CPAN Net-OpenSSH
      1 URL: %CPAN %name
      1 Url: %CPAN MouseX-Foreign
      1 Url: %CPAN MooseX-Clone
      1 Url: %CPAN Moo
      1 Url: %CPAN MojoX-Renderer-Xslate
      1 Url: %CPAN Mojolicious
      1 Url: %CPAN Module-Install-XSUtil
      1 Url: %CPAN Module-Install-ReadmeFromPod
      1 Url: %CPAN Module-Install-CheckLib
      1 Url: %CPAN Module-Implementation
      1 Url: %CPAN(%module)
      1 Url: %CPAN Minilla
      1 Url: %CPAN MetaCPAN-API
      1 Url: %CPAN Mcrypt
      1 Url: %CPAN Math-FFT
      1 Url: %CPAN Math-Complex
      1 Url: %CPAN Log-Any
      1 Url: %CPAN Lingua-JA-Regular-Unicode
      1 Url: %CPAN JavaScript-Value-Escape
      1 Url: %CPAN JavaScript-V8
      1 Url: %CPAN JavaScript-Minifier
      1 Url: %CPAN JavaScript-Beautifier
      1 Url: %CPAN IO-Socket-IP
      1 Url: %CPAN IO-FDPass
      1 Url: %CPAN HTTP-Session
      1 Url: %CPAN HTML-StickyQuery
      1 Url: %CPAN HTML-Shakan
      1 Url: %CPAN HTML-FillInForm-Lite
      1 Url: %CPAN Hash-MultiValue
      1 Url: %CPAN Gtk3
      1 Url: %CPAN Glib-Object-Introspection
      1 URL: %CPAN GD
      1 Url: %CPAN Future
      1 Url: %CPAN FormValidator-Lite
      1 Url: %CPAN Filesys-Notify-Simple
      1 Url: %CPAN File-Path-Tiny
      1 Url: %CPAN FCGI-Client
      1 Url: %CPAN ExtUtils-H2PM
      1 Url: %CPAN ExtUtils-CChecker
      1 Url: %CPAN Eval-Context
      1 Url: %CPAN Error
      1 Url: %CPAN DynaLoader-Functions
      1 URl: %CPAN %dist
      1 Url: %CPAN Devel-PatchPerl
      1 Url: %CPAN Devel-CallParser
      1 Url: %CPAN Devel-CallChecker
      1 Url: %CPAN Debug-Client
      1 Url: %CPAN Data-Section-Simple
      1 URL: %CPAN Data-MessagePack
      1 Url: %CPAN Data-Localize
      1 Url: %CPAN Dancer-Template-Xslate
      1 Url: %CPAN Dancer-Session-Cookie
      1 Url: %CPAN Dancer-Plugin-Database
      1 Url: %CPAN Dancer
      1 Url: %CPAN CSS-Compressor
      1 Url: %CPAN CPAN-Perl-Releases
      1 Url: %CPAN Convert-Bencode
      1 Url: %CPAN Config-Identity
      1 Url: %CPAN Class-Load-XS
      1 Url: %CPAN CHI
      1 Url: %CPAN CGI-Emulate-PSGI
      1 Url: %CPAN CGI-Compile
      1 Url: %CPAN Cairo-GObject
      1 Url: %CPAN Boulder
      1 URL: %CPAN B-Flags
      1 Url: %CPAN B-Debug
      1 URL: %CPAN B-C
      1 Url: %CPAN App-perlbrew
      1 Url: %CPAN App-cpanminus
      1 Url: %CPAN Apache-LogFormat-Compiler
      1 Url: %CPAN AnyEvent-HTTP
      1 Url: %CPAN AnyEvent-Gearman
      1 Url: %CPAN AnyEvent-Fork
      1 Url: %CPAN Amon2-Lite
      1 Url: %CPAN Amon2


-- 
ldv