From mboxrd@z Thu Jan 1 00:00:00 1970 Return-Path: Date: Sun, 10 Jan 2010 22:59:44 +0300 From: "Dmitry V. Levin" To: ALT Devel discussion list Message-ID: <20100110195944.GG5842@wo.int.altlinux.org> Mail-Followup-To: ALT Devel discussion list References: <4B48E735.6040908@altlinux.ru> <20100109223125.GA14247@wo.int.altlinux.org> <20100110174641.GV1710@osdn.org.ua> Mime-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: multipart/signed; micalg=pgp-sha1; protocol="application/pgp-signature"; boundary="S5HS5MvDw4DmbRmb" Content-Disposition: inline In-Reply-To: <20100110174641.GV1710@osdn.org.ua> X-fingerprint: FE4C 93AB E19A 2E4C CB5D 3E4E 7CAB E6AC 9E35 361E Subject: Re: [devel] git submodules vs gear X-BeenThere: devel@lists.altlinux.org X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.12 Precedence: list Reply-To: ALT Linux Team development discussions List-Id: ALT Linux Team development discussions List-Unsubscribe: , List-Archive: List-Post: List-Help: List-Subscribe: , X-List-Received-Date: Sun, 10 Jan 2010 19:59:44 -0000 Archived-At: List-Archive: List-Post: --S5HS5MvDw4DmbRmb Content-Type: text/plain; charset=koi8-r Content-Disposition: inline Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable On Sun, Jan 10, 2010 at 07:46:41PM +0200, Michael Shigorin wrote: > On Sun, Jan 10, 2010 at 01:31:25AM +0300, Dmitry V. Levin wrote: > > Now imagine that this commit id uses submodules and required external > > commit objects are missing, because no git repository that uses > > submodules is required to be self-contained. In this case, gear would > > have to attempt to fetch these commits from internet. This is NOT > > reliable, and gear would not be able to guarantee reproducibly. >=20 > =E3=C9=D4=C9=D2=D5=D1 https://bugzilla.altlinux.org/show_bug.cgi?id=3D179= 14#c24: > > =F0=D2=C9=D7=CE=C5=D3=C5=CE=C9=C5 =D0=CF=C4=C4=C5=D2=D6=CB=C9 submodule= =CE=C5 =C4=CF=CC=D6=CE=CF =D3=CC=CF=CD=C1=D4=D8 =DC=D4=D5 =C7=C1=D2=C1=CE= =D4=C9=C0. >=20 > =EE=C5 =CD=CF=D6=C5=DB=D8 =C4=C1=D4=D8 =C7=C1=D2=C1=CE=D4=C9=C0 -- =CE=C5= =C4=C1=D7=C1=CA. =ED=CE=C5 =CE=D5=D6=CE=CF, =DE=D4=CF=C2=D9 =D0=C1=CB=C5=D4 =D7=CF=D3=D0=D2= =CF=C9=DA=D7=CF=C4=C9=CD=CF =D3=CF=C2=C9=D2=C1=CC=D3=D1 =CE=C1 =C9=DA=CF=CC= =C9=D2=CF=D7=C1=CE=CE=CF=CD =CF=D4 =D7=CE=C5=DB=CE=C5=C7=CF =CD=C9=D2=C1 =D3=C5=D2=D7=C5=D2=C5. =E5=D3=CC=C9 = =C9=CE=D3=D4=D2=D5=CD=C5=CE=D4 =CE=C5 =C4=C1=A3=D4 =CD=CE=C5 =D4=C1=CB=CF= =CA =C7=C1=D2=C1=CE=D4=C9=C9, =D4=CF =CD=CE=C5 =D4=C1=CB=CF=CA =C9=CE=D3=D4=D2=D5=CD=C5=CE=D4 =CE=C5 =CE= =D5=D6=C5=CE. > =EF=D3=CF=C2=C5=CE=CE=CF =C5=D3=CC=C9 =CF=D0=C9=D2=C1=C5=DB=D8=D3=D1 =CE= =C1 > =D5=D3=CC=D5=C7=C9 =D0=CF=D3=D2=C5=C4=CE=C9=CB=CF=D7. git =CB=CF=C7=C4=C1= -=D4=CF =C4=C1=D7=CE=CF =CD=CF=C7 =C7=C1=D2=C1=CE=D4=C9=D2=CF=D7=C1=D4=D8 _= =D0=CF=CC=CE=D5=C0_ > =C9=D3=D4=CF=D2=C9=C0, =C1 =D0=CF=D4=CF=CD =D0=CF=D1=D7=C9=CC=C9=D3=D8 sh= allow clones =C9 submodules (=D0=D2=C9=DE=A3=CD =CE=C5 > =CF=D4 =D0=D2=C9=C8=CF=D4=C9 =C9=CC=C9 "=D2=C1=DA=D2=C1=C2=CF=D4=CB=C9 = =D2=C1=C4=C9 =D2=C1=DA=D2=C1=C2=CF=D4=CB=C9") =C9 =DC=D4=C1 =C7=C1=D2=C1=CE= =D4=C9=D1 =D3=D4=C1=CC=C1 > =CF=C7=D2=C1=CE=C9=DE=C5=CE=CE=CF=CA. =F3=CF=C2=D3=D4=D7=C5=CE=CE=CF, = =DE=D4=CF legion@ =C9 =C7=CF=D7=CF=D2=C9=D4 =D7 #c45. shallow clones =C9 submodules =CE=C5 =CE=C1=D2=D5=DB=C1=C0=D4 =C7=CC=C1=D7= =CE=CF=C7=CF =D3=D7=CF=CA=D3=D4=D7=C1 git -- =C7=C1=D2=C1=CE=D4=C9=C9 =CE=C5=C9=DA=CD=C5=CE=CE=CF=D3=D4=C9 =C9=D3=D4=CF=D2=C9=C9. =E1 =D4=CF, = =DE=D4=CF =DE=C1=D3=D4=D8 =CB=CF=CD=CD=C9=D4=CF=D7 =CD=CF=D6=C5=D4 =C2=D9= =D4=D8 =CF=C6=CF=D2=CD=CC=C5=CE=C1 =D4=C1=CB=C9=CD =CF=C2=D2=C1=DA=CF=CD, =DE=D4=CF=C2=D9 =D3=CE=D1=D4=D8 =CF=C2=D1=DA=C1=D4= =C5=CC=D8=CE=CF=D3=D4=D8 =CC=CF=CB=C1=CC=D8=CE=CF=C7=CF =D2=C1=DA=CD=C5=DD= =C5=CE=C9=D1 -- =DC=D4=CF =CE=C5 =CD=C5=CE=D1=C5=D4 =D3=D5=D4=C9 =C4=C5=CC=C1 =C4=CC=D1 git. =F7=D3=A3 =D4=C1=CB=C9 =CE=C1=C4= =CF =D0=CF=CE=C9=CD=C1=D4=D8, =DE=D4=CF =D5 git =C9 gear =D2=C1=DA=CE=D9=C5 =DA=C1=C4=C1=DE=C9. > =E3=C9=D4=C9=D2=D5=D1 #c26 =C9 #c34: > > =EE=C1=D2=D5=DB=C1=C5=D4=D3=D1 =D0=D2=C9=CE=C3=C9=D0 =C4=CF=D3=D4=C1=D4= =CF=DE=CE=CF=D3=D4=C9 =CB=CF=CD=CD=C9=D4=C1. >=20 > =EE=D5 =C9 =DE=D4=CF? =EE=C5 =CD=CF=D6=C5=DB=D8 =D2=C5=DB=C9=D4=D8 =D0= =D2=CF=C2=CC=C5=CD=D5 =DA=C1 =DE=C5=CC=CF=D7=C5=CB=C1 -- =CE=C5 =CD=C5=DB= =C1=CA =C5=CD=D5 > =D3=C1=CD=CF=CD=D5 =D2=C5=DB=C1=D4=D8 =C9=C8, =D3=CF=DA=C4=C1=D7=C1=D1 = =CE=C5=D0=D2=C5=CF=C4=CF=CC=C9=CD=D9=C5. "=EE=C5 =CE=C1=D7=D2=C5=C4=C9". >=20 > =E1 =CB=CC=C0=DE=C5=D7=D9=C5 =D0=D2=C9=CE=C3=C9=D0=D9, =CE=C1 =CB=CF=D4= =CF=D2=D9=C5 =CF=D0=C9=D2=C1=C0=D4=D3=D1 hasher, gear =C9 =D0=CF=C4=CF=C2= =CE=D9=C5 > =C9=CE=D3=D4=D2=D5=CD=C5=CE=D4=D9 -- =CE=C5=D0=CC=CF=C8=CF =C2=D9=CC=CF = =C2 =CF=D0=C9=D3=D9=D7=C1=D4=D8 =D7 =C9=C8 =C4=CF=CB=D5=CD=C5=CE=D4=C1=C3= =C9=C9. =F1 =D3=D4=C1=D2=C1=C0=D3=D8 =D7 =CD=C5=D2=D5 =D3=D7=CF=C9=C8 =D3=C9=CC =C9= =D7=CF=DA=CD=CF=D6=CE=CF=D3=D4=C5=CA. > =F0=CF=CB=C1 =DE=D4=CF =CF=D4=D3=D5=D4=D3=D4=D7=C9=C5 =D0=CF=C4=C4=C5=D2= =D6=CB=C9 git submodule =D7 =D3=C9=DA=C9=C6=CE=CF=CD gear > =D0=D2=CF=D4=C9=D7=CF=D2=C5=DE=C9=D4 =C5=C7=CF =D6=C5 =C4=CF=CB=D5=CD=C5= =CE=D4=C9=D2=CF=D7=C1=CE=CE=CF=CA =C9=C4=C5=C5 ("=D3=CF=C2=C9=D2=C1=D4=D8 = =D0=C1=CB=C5=D4=D9 > =C9=DA =D0=D2=CF=C9=DA=D7=CF=CC=D8=CE=CF =D5=D3=D4=D2=CF=C5=CE=CE=CF=C7= =CF git-=D2=C5=D0=CF=DA=C9=D4=CF=D2=C9=D1") =C9 =CF=D0=C9=D3=C1=CE=CE=D9=CD > =CF=C7=D2=C1=CE=C9=DE=C5=CE=C9=D1=CD, =CE=C1=CB=CC=C1=C4=D9=D7=C1=C5=CD= =D9=CD =CE=C1 =D3=D4=D2=D5=CB=D4=D5=D2=D5 =D2=C5=D0=CF=DA=C9=D4=CF=D2=C9=D1. =EB=CF=C7=C4=C1 =C2=D9=CC =CE=C1=D0=C9=D3=C1=CE =DC=D4=CF=D4 =D4=C5=CB=D3= =D4, git submodule =CE=C5 =C2=D9=CC=CF =C4=C1=D6=C5 =D7 =D0=D2=CF=C5=CB=D4= =C5. =EF=DE=C5=D7=C9=C4=CE=CF, =D4=C5=CB=D3=D4 =D4=D2=C5=C2=D5=C5=D4=D3=D1 =C1= =CB=D4=D5=C1=CC=C9=DA=C9=D2=CF=D7=C1=D4=D8. > =F0=D2=C9 =DC=D4=CF=CD =D5=D0=CF=CD=D1=CE=D5=D4=D9=CA =D4=CF=C2=CF=CA =D0= =D2=C9=CE=C3=C9=D0 =D7 ABOUT.ru.utf8 =CE=C5 =CF=D0=C9=D3=C1=CE -- > =D7=D3=CB=CF=CC=D8=DA=D8 =D0=D2=CF=D3=CB=C1=CB=C9=D7=C1=C5=D4 =D7=CF =C6= =D2=C1=DA=C5 "=D3=CF=C7=CC=C1=D3=CE=CF =CB=CF=D4=CF=D2=D9=CD =D0=D2=CF=C9= =DA=D7=CF=C4=C9=D4=D3=D1 > =DC=CB=D3=D0=CF=D2=D4 =C9=DA =CB=CF=CD=CD=C9=D4=C1 =D2=C5=D0=CF=DA=C9=D4= =CF=D2=C9=D1 (=D7 =C6=CF=D2=CD=D5, =C9=DA =CB=CF=D4=CF=D2=CF=CA =CD=CF=D6= =CE=CF > =CF=C4=CE=CF=DA=CE=C1=DE=CE=CF =C9=DA=C7=CF=D4=CF=D7=C9=D4=D8 srpm-=D0=C1= =CB=C5=D4 =C9=CC=C9 =DA=C1=D0=D5=D3=D4=C9=D4=D8 =D3=C2=CF=D2=CB=D5)" =D2=C1= =DA=D7=C5. >=20 > =F4=CF =C5=D3=D4=D8 =D4=D7=CF=D1 =D0=CF=DA=C9=C3=C9=D1 =CE=C1=D2=D5=DB=C1= =C5=D4 =D1=D7=CE=CF =D3=C6=CF=D2=CD=D5=CC=C9=D2=CF=D7=C1=CE=CE=D9=CA =D0=D2= =C9=CE=C3=C9=D0, > =C4=C1=D6=C5 =C5=D3=CC=C9, =CB=C1=CB =D7=D9=D1=D3=CE=D1=C5=D4=D3=D1 =D7 = =C2=C1=C7=C5 =D3 =D0=C1=D4=DE=C5=CD, =CF=D0=C9=D2=C1=C5=D4=D3=D1 =CE=C1 =C4= =D2=D5=C7=CF=CA > -- =CE=C9=C7=C4=C5 =CE=C5 =CF=D0=D5=C2=CC=C9=CB=CF=D7=C1=CE=CE=D9=CA =C4= =CF =CF=C2=D3=D5=D6=C4=C5=CE=C9=D1 =D7 =C2=C1=C7=C5, =CB=C1=CB =D0=CF=CE=C9= =CD=C1=C0. =EF=DE=C5=D7=C9=C4=CE=CF, =C6=CF=D2=CD=D5=CC=C9=D2=CF=D7=CB=C9 =D0=CF=D2=C1= =CF=C2=CE=CF=D7=C9=D4=D8, =DE=D4=CF=C2=D9 =CF=CE=C9 =CC=D5=DE=DB=C5 =CF=D4= =D2=C1=D6=C1=CC=C9 =D2=C5=C1=CC=D8=CE=D5=C0 =CB=C1=D2=D4=C9=CE=D5. > > As you see, there is a fundamental problem: GIT submodule breaks > > repository completeness, but gear requires git repositories to be > > self-contained. I have no idea how to avoid this problem. >=20 > =E9=D3=D0=D2=C1=D7=C9=D4=D8 =CF=D6=C9=C4=C1=CE=C9=D1 gear =CE=C1 =D3=CF= =CF=D4=D7=C5=D4=D3=D4=D7=D5=C0=DD=C9=C5 =CE=C1=C2=CC=C0=C4=C1=C5=CD=CF=CA > =C4=C5=CA=D3=D4=D7=C9=D4=C5=CC=D8=CE=CF=D3=D4=C9, =D2=C1=DA=D5=CD=C5=C5= =D4=D3=D1. =F0=CF=D7=D4=CF=D2=C0 =C5=DD=A3 =D2=C1=DA: =CD=CE=C5 =CE=D5=D6=CE=CF, =DE= =D4=CF=C2=D9 gear =D2=C5=DB=C1=CC =D7=D0=CF=CC=CE=C5 =D0=D2=CF=D3=D4=D5=C0 = =C9 =D0=CF=CE=D1=D4=CE=D5=C0 =DA=C1=C4=C1=DE=D5 (=D1 =CE=C1=D0=C9=D3=C1=CC =D7=D9=DB=C5, =CB=C1=CB=D5=C0= ). >=20 > =F7=CF=DA=CD=CF=D6=CE=CF, =CF=C2=D1=DA=C1=D7 =DA=C1=CC=C9=D7=C1=D4=D8 =C9= =D3=D0=CF=CC=D8=DA=D5=C5=CD=D9=C5 =C4=CC=D1 =D3=D5=C2=CD=CF=C4=D5=CC=C5=CA = =D2=C5=D0=CF =CE=C1 > git.alt =FC=D4=CF =CE=C5 =D0=D2=C5=C4=D3=D4=C1=D7=CC=D1=C5=D4=D3=D1 =D7=CF=DA=CD=CF= =D6=CE=D9=CD. > =C9 =D5=CB=C1=DA=D9=D7=C1=D4=D8 =D3=CF=CF=D4=D7=C5=D4=D3=D4=D7=C9=C5 =C7= =C4=C5-=CE=C9=D4=D8 =D7 .gear/submodules > =D7=CF =C9=DA=C2=C5=D6=C1=CE=C9=C5 =D4=D5=D0=CF=CA =C1=D7=D4=CF=CD=C1=D4= =C9=DE=C5=D3=CB=CF=CA =D4=D2=C1=D4=D9 =D7=D2=C5=CD=C5=CE=C9 =C9 =D4=D2=C1= =C6=C9=CB=C1. >=20 > =F0=D2=C9 =DC=D4=CF=CD =D4=C5=C8=CE=C9=DE=C5=D3=CB=C9=CA =CD=C5=D2=D6 =CD= =CF=D6=CE=CF =C4=C5=CC=C1=D4=D8 =D0=D2=D1=CD=CF =D0=C5=D2=C5=C4 =D3=CB=D2= =D5=DE=C9=D7=C1=CE=C9=C5=CD > =D4=C1=D2=C2=CF=CC=C1, =CB=C1=CB =D0=CF=CE=C9=CD=C1=C0. =E9 =D2=C5=D0=CF= =DE=C9=D3=D4=D9=C5, =C9 =E4=C9=CD=C1 =C4=CF=D7=CF=CC=C5=CE. =F3=C2=CF=D2=CF=DE=CE=D9=CA =D4=DC=C7 =C4=CF=CC=D6=C5=CE =D5=CB=C1=DA=D9=D7= =C1=D4=D8 =CE=C1 =CB=CF=CD=CD=C9=D4, =DA=C1=CD=D9=CB=C1=CE=C9=C5 =CB=CF=D4= =CF=D2=CF=C7=CF =CE=C1=C8=CF=C4=C9=D4=D3=D1 =D7 =D2=C5=D0=CF=DA=C9=D4=CF=D2=C9=C9 =C3=C5=CC=C9=CB=CF=CD =C9 =D0=C5=D2= =C5=C4=C1=A3=D4=D3=D1 =C2=C1=DA=CF=D7=D9=CD=C9 =CF=D0=C5=D2=C1=C3=C9=D1=CD= =C9 (git fetch =C9 git push) =C2=C5=DA =D0=CF=D4=C5=D2=D8. =F7=D3=A3 =CF=D3=D4=C1=CC=D8=CE=CF= =C5 -- =C4=C5=D4=C1=CC=C9 =D2=C5=C1=CC=C9=DA=C1=C3=C9=C9. --=20 ldv --S5HS5MvDw4DmbRmb Content-Type: application/pgp-signature Content-Disposition: inline -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Version: GnuPG v1.4.10 (GNU/Linux) iEYEARECAAYFAktKMbAACgkQfKvmrJ41Nh5JBgCdEjjyMLI8uT+wlYs2Pw+dkM+e CR0An1f1VPQRfPLL/Daejyyjn13oCV1n =BNZe -----END PGP SIGNATURE----- --S5HS5MvDw4DmbRmb--